Search

Self Care Pharmacy Blog

 

Saturated Fat Not Harmful?

November 22nd, 2013

By Megan Buck, PharmD Student Cedarville University

In 1970, Ancel Keys’ “seven countries study” correlated the incidence of coronary heart disease and total cholesterol concentrations then observed a correlation between heart disease and saturated fat.1  Due to this study, saturated fat has been held responsible for cardiovascular risks.  Since then, scientists have reviewed several studies and examined the differences between types of fats and cholesterols.  New scientific evidence suggests that the last forty years of convincing people to remove saturated fat from their diets actually increased their cardiovascular risks.2

Aseem Malhotra of Croydon University Hospital in London recently published an article explaining this discovery.  “Saturated Fat Is Not the Major Issue” describes the importance of saturated fat in the diet.  Consuming saturated fat is not harmful, but we should be concerned with overmedicating with statin drugs.2 3  A diet consisting of a maximum of 10% of total nutrients coming from saturated fat has not be proven efficient at reducing cholesterol or reducing cardiovascular risks.  Saturated fat produced large and light-weight (Type A) LDL particles rather than the small and heavy (Type B) particles, the later are likely responsible for cardiovascular disease.2  Also, Malhotra states that studies found processed meats contribute more to coronary heart disease than dairy products and red meat.  Kewick and Pawan’s study showed that a group with a 90% fat-consuming diet lost more weight than groups with 90% protein and 90% carbohydrates, indicating that fat does not have to be terrible in the diet.  Fat-free food is not necessarily healthy because the saturated fat is often replaced with sugar, which is being investigated for lowering HDL cholesterol.  Statins are very popular in the US and UK, partially because the Framingham heart study claimed total cholesterol was a risk factor for coronary artery disease.2

I agree with Aseem Malhotra’s article; he supports his point with the literature.  My search of the literature also yielded a recent meta-analysis and a systematic review that support Malhotra’s conclusion that saturated fat is not the major issue.  Patty W Siri-Tarino et al. performed a meta-analysis to see how reducing saturated fat influenced coronary heart disease (CHD), stroke, and cardiovascular disease and concluded that saturated fat does not increase CHD or cardiovascular disease.The discussion of statin therapy is beyond the scope of this post, however the decision to take a statin should be discussed with a medical provider, some patients may still benefit from a statin if they have already had a heart attack.

A patient can eat foods containing cholesterol without getting a heart attack.5  For example, even though egg yolks have cholesterol, they have thirteen essential nutrients, so they should not be automatically eliminated from the diet.  However, it is noteworthy that people typically do not consume only one nutrient per meal.  Saturated fat should be consumed in context of a balanced meal.  Our bodies crave different foods because of the nutrients in them.  Strictly limiting a person to a diet of a few items would not be my primary recommendation for my patients.

This information will slightly change my self-care recommendation because it differs from the dietary standard of care.  If you have high cholesterol and high cardiovascular risk, you may eat saturated fats, dairy products and red meats but should minimize or avoid intake of trans fats and processed meats.  Red meats are not even particularly high in saturated fat.6  O’Sullivan et al. conducted a meta-analysis which demonstrates that large consumptions of the fat-containing foods of butter, cheese, yogurt, and milk “were not associated with a significantly increased risk of mortality compared” with small consumptions.7  Fat-free foods may not be a better choice than regular-fat foods containing saturated fat because the saturated fat is often replaced with sugar.2  Scientists are currently investigating whether sugar leads to low amounts of the “good” HDL cholesterol and raised triglycerides, or fat in the blood.If you have high blood pressure, I encourage you to limit your caffeine intake.

High cholesterol does not appear to increase risk risk for heart disease.  High cholesterol may be falsely accused for heart disease, further studies need to be identified to determine if statins or any cholesterol lowering therapy is beneficial when targeting cholesterol numbers alone.  Involving the patient in discussion of therapy and treating the whole patient vs. numbers from a holistic approach may be more fruitful.

Does this study affect your current perception of treating high cholesterol?  How would you counsel your patients with high cholesterol after reading this post?  What other foods should be avoided in patients with increased cardiovascular risks?

 

References

  1. Available at: http://www.epi.umn.edu/cvdepi/study.asp?id=12. Accessed November 12, 2013.
  2. Malhotra A. Saturated Fat Is Not the Major Issue. BMJ. 2013;347(oct22 1):f6340. Accessed November 1, 2013.
  3. Available at: http://www.medterms.com/script/main/art.asp?articlekey=33979. Accessed November 2, 2013.
  4. Siri-tarino PW, Sun Q, Hu FB, Krauss RM. Meta-analysis of prospective cohort studies evaluating the association of saturated fat with cardiovascular disease. Am J Clin Nutr. 2010;91(3):535-46.
  5. Kresser C. The Diet-Heart Myth: Cholesterol and Saturated Fat Are Not the Enemy. Available at: http://chriskresser.com/the-diet-heart-myth-cholesterol-and-saturated-fat-are-not-the-enemy. Accessed November 5, 2013.
  6. Kresser C. New Study Puts Final Nail in the “Saturated Fat Causes Heart Disease” Coffin. Available at: http://chriskresser.com/new-study-puts-final-nail-in-the-saturated-fat-causes-heart-disease-coffin. Accessed November 5, 2013.
  7. O’Sullivan T, Hafekost K, Mitrou F, Lawrence D. Food Sources of Saturated Fat and the Association With Mortality: A Meta-Analysis. American Journal Of Public Health [serial online]. September 2013;103(9):e31-e42. Available from: Business Source Complete, Ipswich, MA. Accessed November 1, 2013.

Tags: ,

6 Responses to “Saturated Fat Not Harmful?”

  1. Julie K Cummings Says:

    I think that this study does have a lot of relevancy to it. The new diets that have been around such as the Adkins diet and the Whet belly diet have proven to decrease weight, sugar levels and cholesterol, which goes against what us Americans have been taught since the 1970’s. I agree with you Megan, that I would recommend moderation of certain foods and to trim fats off of meats instead of trimming them out of the diet completely. I would also recommend decreasing the carbohydrates and processed foods possibly a little more than saturated fats. I think that losing a little weight would prove advantageous for people with high cholesterol. I know that statins are utilized a lot in treating high cholesterol and I don’t disapprove of them, I am sure that they are helpful for certain people.

  2. Rebecca A Kyper Says:

    This article was very informational. I can remember sitting in elementary school gym class and being taught that saturated fats are bad. Then all of the sudden there was a big push to eliminate trans fats from the diet. The evidence is always shifting and changing. I think what you pointed out was very beneficial and I would recommend that patients would also stay away from processed meats and trans fats as well. I would also suggest that they would not eliminate the saturated fats from their diet, but stress a balanced diet. I would also highly encourage exercise because I think that being in shape will allow the body to deal with eating certain foods better.

  3. Jesse D Hickey Says:

    It sometimes feels like a cop out when a doctor prescribes a statin medication in a patient with high cholesterol rather than reviewing their diet. It seems as if the doctor wants to treat the symptoms rather than the problem itself. Doctors are not wholly to blame obviously since the patient is the one choosing to eat processed meat, trans fats, and other high fatty foods. Robbing the body completely one or more substances like fat free foods is probably not the best way to go but rather a balanced diet as you said.

  4. Lauren Callahan Says:

    This study most definitely affects my perception of treating high cholesterol. It was interesting to point out the Framingham heart study. So many conclusions have been drawn from that one study in particular. I do not really doubt the results from that study. However, I do doubt some of the conclusions that were drawn from that study due to this post. The Framingham study was a cohort study measuring the correlations between specific variables. Because of this, no cause and effect conclusions can be drawn from it. This includes the idea that saturated fat causes cardiovascular disease as your post so pointed out. In light of this, however, I do not think my recommendations to patients would change until more studies came out confirming the new study. I would, as you said, recommend that my patients avoid caffeine too.

  5. Nicholas C Daniels Says:

    I thought this article was very helpful in clearing up some misconceptions I had about cholesterol. I feel that American society today tends to lean to heavily on the use of medications to solve their health related issues. I feel that, to piggy back off what you said, a balanced diet in moderation, plus consistent exercise to improve cardiovascular health, could be more beneficial than some of the more widely accepted medicinal treatment options, like statins which can lead to liver damage and severe muscle cramping.

  6. Megan Buck Says:

    Thank you for your comments!

    Julie, I appreciate that you took ownership of the information presented and thought about how you would turn it into a recommendation for your patients. Losing weight could definitely help patients with cholesterol. I agree that statins are helpful for many patients, but should not be the only treatment for high cholesterol.

    Rebecca, I am glad that you emphasize the importance of a balanced diet, including one with saturated fat, alongside exercise.

    That is an interesting observation, Jesse. Statin therapy alone seems like the easy way to help the patient. Communication between the physician, pharmacist, and patient to change the patient’s diet, exercise, and medication regimens is likely to be more effective than statin therapy alone. Talking to the patient and developing a more comprehensive treatment shows a higher level of patient care.

    Lauren, thank you for seriously evaluating the studies involved. Several articles have been posted in the last few years arguing that saturated fat does not lead to cardiovascular risks. A possible further direction of this research could be re-evaluating the Framingham heart study.

    Nick, I agree with your comments and perspective. Medications are not the only way to become healthier. Thank you for mentioning possible long-term effects of statin therapy. To add to your point, diet changes will make the statin therapy more effective since the patient’s body will be “more focused” on lowering cholesterol.

    Thank you again for discussing this issue.

Leave a Reply